Loyalty

Are digital loyalty cards worth it for a coffee shop?

19 November 2026·2 min read·By Nathan Hobden

For a coffee shop, regulars are everything. A loyalty card is meant to bring them back more often, but is a digital one worth paying for? The answer comes down to some simple maths.

Do the maths for your café

Take your average spend per visit and work out how many extra visits a month would cover the cost. As an example, Kyco Loyalty is £150 a month ex VAT, about £4.93 a day. If your average spend is £5, that is roughly one extra visit a day across your whole customer base.

Example

If 100 regulars each come in just one extra time a month, at £5 a visit, that’s £500 extra a month against a £150 cost. These figures are illustrative, so use your own numbers.

Why digital beats paper

  • Cards can’t be lost, forgotten or faked
  • You can see who your regulars are and how often they visit
  • You can message them directly, for example “double stamps this Tuesday”

More on this in why paper stamp cards are costing you regulars.

What to look for

  • No app to download. Customers won’t install an app for one café. Cards in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet take seconds to add.
  • Fast stamping. Your team should be able to stamp a card in a second or two at the counter.
  • Free messaging. Push messages to the card shouldn’t cost credits.
  • No long contract. You should be able to stop if it isn’t working.

When it isn’t worth it

If most of your trade is one-off tourists or passing commuters, a loyalty card will do less. In that case, start by capturing guest details through your guest Wi-Fi and build from there.

The verdict

For most coffee shops with a regular local crowd, a digital loyalty card pays for itself quickly. Check your own numbers, try it with no long contract, and measure the extra visits.